“The fact that there were mistakes in the early experiments does not mean that the research is illegitimate.”
One of the issues critics raised about Pons and Fleischmann’s experiments was that they were not replicable. Still, as Dr. Alexandrov explains, there are several reasons why this is the case, including the fact that the constantan wire (the site of fusion in Dr. Alexandrov’s experiment) requires a specific temperature for the reaction to happen. So, for the experiment to happen, it must be heated externally to at least 500oC to trigger electrical screening by heavy electrons. When this is done, the ratio of output power to input is about 16 (
for context, the output-to-input ratio of energy from a wind turbine is 3 - 18, depending on weather conditions).